Revenge against whom? What wrong was done in the first place that required revenge? There were hints but no real explanation of why the Sith were so dissatisfied with the status quo. They were in control and the whole universe other than a handful of malcontent Jedi saw Sidious as One of the Good Guys — guess Sidious, like Anakin, grew weary of hiding things. Otherwise why not let the galaxy continue to see certain Sith as good guys and avoid pesky rebellions?
Oy, the craziness of walking around on a spaceship that won’t sit up straight! Of course, how do they decide which way is up in space? All the time Anakin and Palpatine were running, then sliding, then falling down that shaft I was wondering - do they have artificial gravity, or don’t they? They’re not flying away from the side of the shaft, but the ship changes direction and suddenly the wall is the ceiling?
I wondered if the characters weren’t so much acting distressed and angsty as they were trying to save their character while being forced to mouth such clunky dialogue. The only ones who were even partly convincing were Palpatine and Obi-Wan, and when with either of those Anakin managed to improve. “Act like I’m angry/frustrated/distressed? Who needs to act? I hate this line!”
Padme sighing, crying, moping, swooning and dying for no reason? At least her daughter eventually gets to be intelligent. Let’s see — Anakin is chums with the chancellor. Padme sits in the senate chamber and says the Republic is doomed. Then she goes home and cries instead of finding her sekrit hubby and convincing him that his ‘chum’ is bad news? Is this the same chick we saw two movies ago? I seem to recall she wasn’t made of tissue paper before. She could be queen, and senator, and in charge - but she can’t go off somewhere to raise kids by herself. Right.
Was that a C section or a labor-and-deliver? It was so short, yet she yelled so much. Yet the babies looked *perfect.*
Yes, we can fight while surfing down a river of lava and still breathe. We’re Jedi, after all. *eyeroll*
Things I liked: I saw the Millenium Falcon! I want an iguana with gecko feet, big enough to saddle. The saber fight between Yoda and Palpatine was too cool. Ewan! Picturing certain conservatives saying some of the lines given to Sith had its own appeal.
Things I lampooned: Anakin = the black knight? (\Python) “Overuse this sentence construction, I must. Lucas shows the limits of his creative genius, he does.” “Oh Ani… wait, I need to change clothes again, and wear all this jewelry to bed, and you stand over there and watch me brush my hair on the balcony while we read our lines from the teleprompter.”
Most overwhelming: The ships! Everywhere! All around! Too — much — activity — to — enjoy! AAAAH!
Most unconvincing: Anakin’s ten seconds of indecision when he realized that not letting Mace go through with the execution was not wise. He just bounced right up and volunteered for service to the Dark Side. And while we’re at it — the dark side of anything usually pretends it’s really the good side without the label and with less obvious manipulation.
Yeah, Anakin was young, and he kept saying it was for Padme. But that wasn’t very convincing, either. It seemed to me that the movie makers thought him to be entirely motivated by love for her, when a more believable motivation waited in the wings — his ego and his impatience with having to work for power the Jedi way.
Overall impression: It tried to do too much in too little time. It tried to be too many things at once, and ended up failing to do much more than stun with CGI and pathos.
Roommate’s nutshell analysis: “Lucas did better before he had all the special effects at his disposal. He had to tell a story then.”
Yes.