I seem to recall your desire to write House fic, but feeling intimidated by the level of detail necessary in medical terminology.
Have no fear. The writers of House don’t care much about that, actually. Here we are: Television Without Pity » House » Lines In The Sand
There are a number of things wrong with this scenario. This is about Valley Fever, a fungal infection that you can get by inhaling dust kicked up in central regions of California, particularly desert or high desert areas.
Here’s the thing: it ain’t like this.
“He asks Ali if she was in an earthquake during her recent trip to Fresno. She says there was a small one, and House tells her that she’s not in love with him: she has a spore in her brain. Enh, same difference. A fungus called Coccidioides immitis lives in California soil, only to be released into the air by those frequent earthquakes and breathed in by anyone stupid enough to live in the evil dangerous hellpit that is California. It causes the milky tears he saw Ali crying as well as those aches and pains and cold-like symptoms both she and her dad were suffering from. It can also cause “loss of inhibition and judgment,” i.e. thinking House was a great romantic prospect.”
1. NO EARTHQUAKES IN FRESNO. The central valley ‘burg of Fresno lies nowhere close to a fault. The last earthquake I felt was over a decade ago; it sort of jiggled the apartment. The only reason I woke up at all was my bird shrieking — birds are very sensitive to earthquakes. Certainly there was no dust thrown up by it. Earthquakes happen somewhere else, like Coalinga.
There are, however, plenty of construction sites. And those are very good at stirring up dirt, as are dust storms. But we all know California is just shaking itself apart with the earthquakes, so no mundane little thing like a bulldozer will do.
2. The symptoms are half right - Valley Fever can have the cold/flu symptoms, and lots of others that appear some of the time, but not all of the time. “Milky tears” aren’t on the list, nor is loss of inhibition. Sputum, skin lesions, chest pain, headache, rales, meningitis, and other things you can find here can happen. Pretty much everyone who lives in the central valley is exposed; a fraction of those develop symptoms, and lots of us develop a mild case and/or immunity. My grandmother died of complications that came about because she had Valley Fever, not because of the fungus itself. I worked with an African American who missed lots of work because of problems with Valley Fever; he always sounded like he had pneumonia. Simply writing a scrip doesn’t always help. Of course, House might not have known that - but you’d think he would have done a little research and referred the patient to someone with expertise?
Anyone with a link to WebMD could do a better job than this. Also, California=Earthquakes R Us? not so much. Lazy, Lazy. Bottom line? House is ALREADY as poorly researched as most fanfic. We could certainly do better, even if our only resource were wikipedia.
5 comments
Comments feed for this article
October 18, 2006 at 3:01 pm
R.J. Anderson
Actually, I wrote my Housefic some time ago, and got a lot of feedback praising my mad medical researching skillz.
So I was emboldened to do enough research for a second story — only problem is, I’m too busy with Other Stuff to get around to writing it!
Your point about earthquakes in Fresno is indeed… problematic. Why on earth couldn’t they have picked a place which does suffer from regular earthquakes? However, MOPPeT regarding the milky tears, loss of inhibition, etc. was that House made that stuff up to get Ali off his back and was only pretending to be devastated (admittedly, not having to pretend very hard, since his ego was clearly flattered having a 17-year-old nymphet chasing after him) by the “diagnosis”.
October 18, 2006 at 4:55 pm
Lori
They could have simply said she was caught in a dust storm, for that matter. We do have them in California from time to time. She could have been exposed by helping someone garden, or walking past a construction site on the way to 7-11.
I had assumed House to be idiosyncratic, not outright inappropriate. Making stuff up is a bit outside what I would expect from a doctor. I suppose I should tell myself it’s only a tv show and relax already, and get back to packing rather than rant further. So off I go.
October 19, 2006 at 5:40 am
R.J. Anderson
Well, it was harmless stuff he made up, and in a way it was in Ali’s best interests, so I don’t have a problem with it. I find the scene more amusing if I tell myself House was just acting his face off (and it seems to fit with the over-the-top speech he gave her, Casablanca quotes and all).
There is a blog called Polite Dissent that regularly reviews House episodes from a medical standpoint and nitpicks all the things they get wrong. The writer clearly likes the show and is willing to give it a pass if the drama’s good — but as a medical professional he can’t resist setting the score straight.
August 30, 2007 at 1:23 pm
Robby Bobby
House deliberately lied about the spores, he was just doing it to convince the girl that she didn’t really love him. I thought that was obvious, but I guess not
August 30, 2007 at 6:03 pm
Lori
But deliberately lying to a patient about their medical condition is a healthcare no-no regardless. Unless House really doesn’t care if they yank his license, it’s not even in the realm of the believable.