Man Held in Bar Attack Dies After Shootout
This story of a kid who shot up a gay bar and rabbited from police, got in a shootout, and now is dead. It’s been all over the news. People all over blogdom/LJ comment on it — I’ve been cruising through friendslists and noting the reactions.
I can understand a certain amount of anger, horror, etc. because the kid was all up into the Nazi-ness and so forth, and any 18 year old going out of control and shooting people is just Not Good. What I’m seeing in addition to the anger is harsh judgement of the parents — I wonder, at what point do kids become separate entities? Because I seem to recall being not-much-into-hanging-with-the-’rents somewhere around preteen age, 12-14, and doing my own thing and reading what I wanted to read from the library, and thinking my own thoughts, which were very different from the things my parents seemed to be thinking. Excoriating parents up one side and down the other for a teen’s misbehavior isn’t my natural reaction — I feel bad for the parents, who probably stressed and tore their hair out over this kid. If your kid got a tattoo of a swastika wouldn’t you worry? Without real proof of parental indifference, I won’t go to the Bad Place of Parental Damnation.
How much control do you think you’d have over a teenager? If your kid hung up a Nazi propaganda poster, and you said ‘take it down’ and the kid threatened to run away from home and live in the street — what do you value more? The kid’s physical well being, for which you are legally and morally responsible until he’s 18, or not having that poster on your wall?
There are elements of the story that do puzzle me — the kid had a relationship with a 33 year old woman? Most articles say nothing about his family. This was all I came up with (I admit I’m not spending lots of time googling about this) — I quote:
Mr. Robida lived in New Bedford in a three-story white house on County Street with lace curtains in the second-story window. His father left when he was young, Ms. Silva said. His mother was ill throughout his childhood with heart problems and diabetes. Roughly a year ago, doctors amputated her leg, friends said.
Mr. Robida’s only sibling is a 13-year-old sister, Morgan.
Mr. Robida attended New Bedford High School and Dartmouth High School but never finished, according to school records. He dropped out of Dartmouth High in December 2003, eventually attending night school without earning a degree, according to school records.
After leaving school, friends recalled he briefly sorted clothes at the Salvation Army in New Bedford and then worked construction with his father.
In his spare time, he and fellow Insane Clown Posse [band with violent lyrics] fans met at one another’s houses. They played video games, watched television and “chilled.” The friends said Mr. Robida didn’t have a girlfriend and that he smoked marijuana, but nothing stronger.
When police searched Mr. Robida’s house on County Street following the shooting, they found Nazi regalia and anti-Semitic writing on his bedroom walls, according to a police affidavit. Friends said he also wore a fake swastika tattoo on his thumb, but quickly said they’d never heard him express disdain or hatred for anyone.
“He did have Nazi flags in his room, but that doesn’t mean he was a bad person,” Ms. Silva said.
Other friends called it a phase, paraphernalia Mr. Robida was drawn to without any real thought or malice.
So what’s the real story? We don’t know. It doesn’t sound like he had a lot to do with his parents. They make it sound like he’s got his own house, or is renting a room apart from his parents. His mom’s disabled. He has some contact with his dad but who knows how much or the quality of it. Another kid from a broken home, learning to fend for himself.
If you want to blame someone, Blogdom, I think you need to consider that the kid thought for himself and did for himself, and there’s really no one to blame but him, ultimately. The parents probably feel enough self recrimination without your help. What do you expect a single mom with heart problems to do? They’re human. They’re probably like a lot of parents whose kids don’t go on shooting rampages. Bottom line, NONE OF US knows enough about the situation to judge, so what’s with the finger-pointing?